Secret Societies

written by Paul Witcover

Cat Velis, Mireille de Rémy, Alexandra Solarin-these and other characters in The Eight and The Fire–are swept up in the quest for the Montglane Service, the chess set that once belonged to Charlemagne, and we are swept up, along with them. As together we begin to uncover its hidden past, we discover that it may be connected to several mysterious groups possessing esoteric, mystic and/or scientific knowledge going back to ancient times. That knowledge, as we will learn, has been encoded into the pieces and board of the legendary chess set that was originally designed and built in 775 A.D., in Baghdad.

Although Katherine Neville herself invented the mystical chess set which first appears in her novel, The Eight, the “inventor” to whom she attributes its creation, in her imaginative work, was actually a very real, almost monumental, historic figure: the medieval Sufi scientist and Father of Islamic Alchemy, al-Jabir ibn-Hayyan. Indeed, it was Al-Jabir’s extensive writings–many of which are still in print today–that would later inspire, among many others, the subsequent research of that great 14th-century alchemist, Nicolas Flamel (of more recently fictionalized “Harry Potter” fame.)

In The Eight, we find the empress, Catherine the Great of Russia, telling her childhood friend–Helene de Roque, now abbess of Montglane Abbey in the French Pyrenees–the story of how, when Catherine was young, the great mathematician Leonhard Euler had warned her about a secret society of men known as the Brotherhood of Freemasons, who “knew the mysteries of the ancients.” These men, Euler had explained to young Catherine, were the spiritual descendants of the men whose forbidden knowledge al-Jabir had encoded into the Montglane Service. Catherine now seeks the Service and the knowledge it contains in order, she says, to prevent the Freemasons from invoking the powers of the chess set to topple monarchies into the dust and seize control of the world. But the abbess envisions another alternative: “Perhaps their aim is to free the world,” she suggests to the empress.

Then, in The Fire, an allusion to another secret society surfaces, when Alexandra “Xie” Solarin (the daughter of Cat Velis and Russian grandmaster Alexander Solarin from The Eight) first appears as the apprentice of master chef, Rodolfo Boujaron, whose posh Washington, D.C. restaurant is called Sutalde, the Basque word meaning “hearth.” The unusual name of this restaurant actually points us to the secret society which plays a pivotal role in the historic chapters of The Fire: the Carbonari, or Charcoal Burners. “Like the Rosicrucians, Freemasons, the Illuminati,” Xie’s boss Rodo tells her one night when they are alone at the Hearth, “these Charcoal Burners also say they possess a secret wisdom only known by the initiated, such as themselves.” Rodo traces the origins of the society back to ancient, pre-Roman and Greek mystery religions involving the goddess Hestia . . . and he adds that the Montglane Service is the repository of that ancient wisdom, which he believes is recorded in physical form through this very chess set, created by al-Jabir.

Like characters such as Cat and Alexandra, readers themselves of Katherine Neville’s tales are constantly surprised by discovering such unexpected connections between things that, at first, may seem unconnected–by secret histories that reveal people and events in a startling new light, and that turn what we think we know upside down and inside out, until we feel as if we are trembling on the verge of a revelation that will put all those shattered pieces back together into a new pattern that will suddenly make sense of everything . . . a new pattern which is also an old pattern, which may, indeed, be the oldest pattern of all. Gradually, as we read on, it dawns upon us that the secret societies Katherine Neville has carefully introduced into her plot are themselves reflections, or refractions, of a society so secret that it doesn’t even have a name: a most secret society consisting of the players of the great Game that is both symbolized by and resident in the thousand-year-old chess set she created.

It is clear in exploring all of her writings that Katherine Neville has a deep interest in, and has also collected a vast repertoire of knowledge about, certain societies which have themselves been a repository of wisdom from the ancient mystery schools. For instance, in Neville’s story, The Tuesday Club (in the anthology Thriller, 2006)–which takes place on the day and year that Ben Franklin, Thomas Jefferson, and John Adams first met in Paris to turn over the French mission–we learn of some startling connections among early Scottish Freemasonry, ancient Egyptian architecture, and certain mysteries involving musical tones.

Intriguing, yes. However, what exactly constitutes a secret society is a matter of some controversy. Political groups like the Carbonari and certain religious groups, like branches of the Sufis or Shi’a, have had to maintain close secrecy–sometimes, if only for reasons of the personal safety of their members’ lives. While others, like the Freemasons, have historically made little secret of their rites and rituals, their political goals, or their membership rolls–indeed, the Masons take pride in boasting of famous members like George Washington, Benjamin Franklin, and Voltaire. But though their rituals may have been in print for more than 100 years, the meaning behind such rites remains closely guarded among the initiates, who relish the idea that theirs is an ancient wisdom whose underlying meaning can still be protected by secret code words, handshakes, and visual images.

So in real life, how can we define these secret societies that have cropped up repeatedly throughout history, and where have they come from? Are they political organizations or religious entities? Are they terrorist groups like al-Qaeda or occult outfits like the Hermetic Order of the Golden Dawn or college fraternities like Yale’s Skull and Bones society? The answer may be: All of the above.

However, a broad definition is possible. A secret society is a group of like-minded people who share a common objective or belief system, who may strive to keep the fact of their existence secret from the rest of the world (or at least, to cloak the true nature of that existence behind an impenetrable or misleading façade), who may keep their membership hidden (sometimes even from other members), and who claim to possess arcane or esoteric wisdom that is often explicitly linked to an ancient wisdom which has been preserved and communicated over the centuries, or even millennia, through a body of ritual that is generally hierarchical and progressive, with more of the “truth” revealed to initiates the higher they rise in the organization.

Secret societies have been documented since the beginning of recorded history, and likely existed long before. They began as religious organizations, though we must recall that the separation of religion from the secular state is a relatively recent innovation, and even today is by no means the norm throughout most of the world. But in the ancient world there was no distinction whatever. Beginning as early as the world as it is revealed in prehistoric cave paintings, to the Egyptian cult of Isis and Osiris, to the Greek Eleusinian mysteries, to early Christianity itself, the world has been steeped in religious sensibility and belief in the supernatural, with corresponding rites whose secret meaning was closely maintained through a network of initiates and priests. This system of ritual, revelation, and initiation into “the mysteries” provided the fabric, the very lifeblood, of the social order in early societies.

Such secret Orders, and their corresponding rites, were preserved and maintained despite forced migrations, including slavery, or attempts by governments and rival cults alike to eradicate them. As late as the medieval era and beyond, social groups claiming to hold secret wisdom– such as the Gnostics, the Cathars or the Knights Templar, sought to establish their pedigree by linking themselves explicitly to the deep wisdom held by the ancient mystery religions; and scholars have demonstrated, in fact, that such linkages do exist.

Fast forward to modern times. With the Enlightenment, a more secular, scientific, and overtly political outlook permeated Western society, and these elements were reflected in the secret societies that arose at the time, such as the Freemasons and the Carbonari. The political clout of these and other secret societies in modern times has given rise to popular paranoid fantasies in which various historical events are explained by conspiracies orchestrated by invisible puppet masters.

Let’s take a closer look at some of these secret societies. Katherine Neville has provided a reading list of books that may be of interest to those who wish to pursue these topics in greater depth–or who just wish to have fun reading!

Katherine’s “Knights Templar” reading list

(Note: The demise of the Cathars is linked to the destruction of the Knights Templar, therefore a Cathar reading list will be added to this list at a later date.)

The Knights Templar Stephen Howarth

The Rule of the Templars J.M. Upton-Ward

Sacred Sites of the Knights Templars John K Young

The Knights of the Order Ernle Bradford

The Knights Templar and Their Myth Peter Partner

The History of the Knights Templar Charles G. Addison

Addison’s Knights Templars Robert McCoy

(These prior two cover the myth of the Knights in England and Scotland, the Holy Grail and Spear of Longinus)

The Knight in History Francis Gies

The Trial of the Templars Malcolm Barber

The Templar Treasure at Gisors Jean Markale

Guia de la Espana Templaria Juan G. Atienza (A pocket travel guide to Templar sites in Spain, with maps and pictures)

The Knights Templar in the New World William F. Mann (Story of Sir Henry Sinclair and the Grail in Acadia)


The Templars Barbara Frale (A PhD from University of Venice, Frale is an expert on the Crusades and a staff historian at the Vatican Secret Archive. She discovered the Chinon Parchment absolving the Templars. The forward to her book is by Umberto Eco.)

Katherine’s Freemasonry Reading List

Books by Freemasons and other authorities:

Morals and Dogma-Albert Pike

A New Encyclopedia of Freemasonry- A.E. Waite

Duncan’s Ritual-Malcolm C. Duncan (Guide to the 3 degrees of the York Rite)

The Lodge of Washington DC-F.L. Brockett (History from the records of Alexandria Lodge No 22, George Washington’s lodge)

A Dictionary of Freemasonry- Robert McCoy

Freemasonry and the American Indian-William R. Denslow (Missouri Lodge of Research)

Freemasonry: Symbols, Secrets, Significance-W. Kirk McNulty (A gorgeous Thames & Hudson coffee-table book)

Freemasonry in the 13 Colonies-J. Hugo Tatsch

Facts About George Washington as a Freemason-J. Hugo Tatsch

The Meaning of Masonry-W.L. Willamshurst

Hermetic Masonry-Frank C. Higgins

Books by Non-Freemasons (Caution: a few with an Agenda, or even an axe to grind):

The Freemasons: A History of the World’s Most Powerful Secret Society-Jasper Ridley

Freemasonry and its Ancient Mystic Rites-C. W. Leadbeater (Theosophist and Clairvoyant, friend of Blavatsky)

The Temple and the Lodge-Michael Baigent and Richard Leigh (By the guys who gave us Holy Blood, Holy Grail)

The Templar Revelation-Lynn Picknett and Clive Prince (More Blood, Grail, Templars, Masons–and likely the first mention of the Secret Code of Leonardo da Vinci in Chapter One)

Ark of the Covenant, Holy Grail- Henrietta Bernstein (Ark, Grail, and a summary of the history of Western Path Secret Societies)

The Secret Architecture of Our Nation’s Capital: The Masons and the Building of Washington DC-David Ovason

(Freemasonic errors galore–but fun to read!)

The Brotherhood-Stephen Knight (Scandalmongering book by a journalist re: the 1980s actual conspiracy implicating members of the Vatican, the Mafia, Italy’s Banco Ambrosiana, and “Propaganda Due,” a secret (and illegally self-appointed) Freemason lodge. St Peter’s’s Banker by Italian journalist Luigi DiFonzo provides a more accurate analysis of events that are also covered by Francis Coppola in Godfather III.)

Inside the Brotherhood-Martin Short (Scandalmongering “sequel” by a former TV documentary person.)



The Art and Architecture of Freemasonry – James Stevens Curl 

(The author may or may not be a Freemason, but he is a brilliant architectural historian. The bibliography alone is worth gold.)



Books by Lomas and Knight:

Robert Lomas and Christopher Knight are the top-selling Freemason authors in history, and deserve their own section.

Their books involve a re-thinking of biblical and pre-dynastic Egyptian history as interpreted through Masonic rites.

These include:

The Book of Hiram

-The Hiram Key

-The Second Messiah

-Uriel’s Machine

A stand-alone book of Robert Lomas’s:

Turning the Solomon Key: 

George Washington, the Bright Morning Star, and the Secret of Masonic Astrology 

by Robert Lomas 

(Katherine wrote the Preface)

And highly recommended, for its insights into the early British connections of Freemasonry, politics, and science:

Freemasonry and the Birth of Modern Science Robert Lomas (The Foundation of the Royal Society by Freemasons including Robert Boyle, Robert Moray and Christopher Wren, with the patronage of Charles II)

Katherine’s “Assassin” Reading List

As with the Templars and the Cathars, the history of Muhammad and Charlemagne and of the Assassins are all also inextricably interwoven with the story of the Crusades. Therefore, a more extensive book list on important topics about the Crusades will be posted later.

  • “The Assassins” Bernard Lewis (former Princeton professor of Near Eastern studies)
  • “The Templars and the Assassins” James Wasserman (Occult scholar and member of OTO)
  • “Arab Historians of the Crusades” Francesco Gabrieli
  • “Holy War” Karen Armstrong
  • “Saladin in His Time” P.H. Newby
  • “The Crusades” Henry Treece
  • “Chronicles of the Crusades” Joinville and Villehardouin (the two classic Christian accounts)
  • “A History of Secret Societies” Arkon Daraul (1961)
  • “The Secret Societies of All Ages and Countries”(2-vol) Charles William Heckethorn (1875)
    • (The above two books also discuss the Carbonari)



The Crusades through Arab Eyes – Amin Maalouf


Samarcande (a novel) – Amin Maalouf

The fascinating fictional story of three friends who were likely actually acquainted: Omar Khayyam, Vizier Nizam al-Mulkh, and Hassan Sabbah, the founder of the Order of Assassins.


Katherine’s Carbonari Reading List

A History of Secret Societies-Arkon Daraul (1961)

The Secret Societies of All Ages and Countries (2-vol)-Charles William Heckethorn (1875)

The Last Attachment: The Story of Byron and Therese Guiccioli-Iris Origo

Shelley and Byron-Isabel C. Clarke